When considering a new roof for your home, durability, curb appeal, and long-term value are all major factors. For homeowners in Mentor, OH, synthetic cedar roofing has become an increasingly popular option thanks to its classic appearance, low maintenance requirements, and long lifespan. But how much does it actually cost to install this type of roof?
In this guide, we’ll break down the real numbers behind cedar roof cost, what influences the final price, and why synthetic cedar might be the perfect choice for your next roofing project.
What Is Synthetic Cedar Shake Roofing?
Synthetic cedar shake roofing is a high-performance alternative to traditional wooden shakes. Made from engineered materials such as polymers, rubber, and sometimes recycled plastics, synthetic shakes replicate the rustic charm of natural cedar without the common issues like rot, warping, or insect damage.
They’re designed to withstand harsh weather conditions, making them ideal for regions like Mentor, OH, where snow, hail, wind, and temperature swings can take a toll on your home’s exterior.
How Much Does A Synthetic Cedar Roof Cost
The average cedar roof cost for a synthetic system ranges between $13,000 and $24,000, with most homeowners in Mentor, OH, paying around $18,000 for a standard 1,500- to 2,000-square-foot roof. Prices can vary depending on the size and complexity of the roof, labor rates in your area, and the specific brand or style of synthetic cedar selected.
Here’s a breakdown of cedar roof replacement cost by roof size (including materials and labor):
Estimated cedar roof replacement cost by roof size:
- 1,000 sq. ft.: $7,600 – $9,700
- 1,500 sq. ft.: $12,000 – $15,100
- 2,000 sq. ft.: $16,000 – $19,800
- 2,500 sq. ft.: $21,000 – $24,500
- 3,000 sq. ft.: $24,100 – $31,400
These numbers reflect average pricing and can fluctuate based on your home’s roof pitch, accessibility, and whether additional work like underlayment or structural reinforcement is required.
What Affects Cedar Roof Replacement Cost?
While averages help give a sense of budget, several key factors can influence the final cedar roof replacement cost for your Mentor home.
Roof Complexity
A roof with multiple valleys, peaks, dormers, or skylights will require more labor and specialized cuts, leading to higher installation costs.
Tear-Off and Prep Work
Removing an old roof, especially if it has multiple layers, adds time and cost. Prep work also includes inspecting and possibly replacing the underlayment to ensure the roof deck is in good condition.
Permits and Local Codes
In Mentor, OH, building permits are required for roof replacement projects and typically cost around $1,700. A reputable contractor will handle this step as part of your roofing project.
Labor Rates
Labor costs vary by region. In Mentor, roofers typically charge between $40 and $90 per hour per worker. Roofs that are difficult to access or have steep pitches can increase this rate due to safety and equipment considerations.
Material Quality
Not all synthetic shakes are created equal. Premium products with higher impact ratings, UV resistance, and extended warranties will cost more upfront, but offer better long-term value and fewer repair needs.
Comparing Synthetic Cedar to Natural Cedar
Natural cedar roofs offer classic curb appeal, but they come with higher maintenance and shorter lifespans.
Here’s how the two materials compare.
Average Lifespan:
- Synthetic Cedar: 30–50 years
- Natural Cedar: 20–30 years
Maintenance:
- Synthetic Cedar: Minimal
- Natural Cedar: High (requires regular treatment and is prone to rot)
Resistance to Elements:
- Synthetic Cedar: Excellent
- Natural Cedar: Moderate
Energy Efficiency:
- Synthetic Cedar: High
- Natural Cedar: Moderate
Insect and Mold Resistance:
- Synthetic Cedar: Yes
- Natural Cedar: No
Warranty Options:
- Synthetic Cedar: Up to 50 years
- Natural Cedar: Limited
Cost (Materials Only):
- Synthetic Cedar: Lower to moderate
- Natural Cedar: High
Bottom line: While natural cedar has a traditional charm, synthetic cedar offers greater durability, efficiency, and value, especially in Mentor’s variable weather conditions.
Does a Synthetic Cedar Roof Increase Home Value?
Yes! Investing in a synthetic cedar roof can provide a solid return on investment. According to current market data, homeowners can expect to recoup between 30% and 70% of their roofing investment in resale value. A new synthetic cedar roof boosts both aesthetic appeal and buyer confidence by promising decades of performance without demanding upkeep.
Additionally, these roofs may also help reduce homeowners insurance premiums by up to 35%, due to their fire and impact resistance. That’s another smart financial edge when calculating total value, not just cost.
Tips for Reducing Cedar Roof Replacement Cost
While a synthetic cedar roof is an investment, there are ways to minimize costs without compromising quality:
- Use Recycled or Budget-Friendly Brands: Some synthetic products use up to 100% recycled material and still perform exceptionally well.
- DIY Tear-Off (Only If Safe): Doing your own demolition can save $40–$90 per hour, but only attempt this if it’s safe and permitted.
- Compare Quotes from Local Contractors: Rates can vary widely. Getting multiple quotes ensures you get the best value.
- Double Check Warranties: Before paying out of pocket, confirm whether repairs or materials are already covered.
Hire a Roofing Specialist, Not a General Contractor
When replacing a roof, especially with premium materials like synthetic cedar, experience matters. While general contractors may offer roofing as a service, only specialized roofers have the equipment, knowledge, and manufacturer training to install synthetic shake properly.
Poor installation can void your warranty or lead to costly issues down the line, so be sure to hire a licensed, insured local roofing expert in Mentor, OH.
Ready For a New Cedar Roof in Mentor, OH
If you love the timeless look of cedar shake but don’t want the hassle of ongoing upkeep or early replacement, synthetic cedar is a smart alternative. With costs averaging around $13,000 to $24,000 and a life expectancy of up to 50 years, this roofing option offers style, strength, and peace of mind for Mentor homeowners.
Remember, the final cedar roof replacement cost depends on your home’s size, complexity, and the contractor you choose, but with the right team, the investment is well worth it.
Schedule your free inspection today and let our team help you determine the best roofing solution for your needs, budget, and long-term goals.
Your beautiful, worry-free roof starts here.